Back when I was 16 I had a 17 year old girlfriend. She was the first to let me fuck her. She was pretty experienced and I loved being with her. She was a stone cold hottie, and beautiful to boot. Then after about 8 months she was going to college and we were in her dorm room with her room mate away for a long weekend. I was fucking her in her ass and she kept asking me to stop and pull out that she had to go to the bathroom. I was so close to cumming I kept going and she shit all over us both. I stuck it back in and came, then pulled out. She was embarrassed beyond belief. After I washed us both up, we gathered the sheets and got a ton of Lysol in the room. She was so embarrassed she wouldn't see me again. It's been 2 and 1/2 year now and she won't even look at me if we are at the same grocery store. The only time she even talked to me after she broke it off, which was the day after shitting all over us, was at a party where she begged me not to tell her current boyfriend what she'd done.

Beautiful, great body (she still has her original body back after having twins too) sexually open but broke it off because she was embarrassed that she shits.